Saturday, March 16, 2013
So long Reform of the Reform and the Hermeneutic of Continuity?
Posted by
David Werling
Pope Francis, from the very first moment of his Pontificate, made a rather significant liturgical change by appearing after his election without the papal mozzetta and stole. His first Mass as Pope included hauling out the movable, free standing altar that the previous Pontificate had kept in storage. Pope Francis' recent liturgical practices while still Archbishop of Beunos Aires were far from embodying the Ratzinger liturgical aesthetic, which has been dubbed "The Reform of the Reform" or the "Hermeneutic of Continuity", or, from Ratzinger's book, The Spirit of the Liturgy, "The New Liturgical Movement".
There's a new sheriff in town, as the saying goes, and one can get a good feel for the tone and tenure of the new management by the kinds of citizens who are thrilled with that new sheriff. Take, for example, the over-joyed reaction of the priest-sex-abuser-protector, the liturgically (and everything else) liberal, Roger Cardinal Mahony, who enthusiastically tweeted: "Mass with Pope Francis: moving from HIGH Church to LOW and humble Church!"
If Cardinal Mahony, who protected sex abusing priests, and then pridefully attacked his successor and other detractors, for calling him to task for his clear negligence and disregard for the welfare of children and teen-agers, if this guy, who personifies the "filth" in the curia, is happy about Pope Francis, can we reasonably expect this new Pope to clean up that filth? It seems to me that the filth got its way. But that is a topic for another time. Maybe the giddy enthusiasm of the filth will be surprised in the future.
What is crystal clear, however, and what ought to be striking fear into the Hermeneutic of Continuity/Reform of the Reform crowd is that their project, on which they spent so much time and energy and emotion, has perceptibly come to an end. As I've stated before, this might be a good that God brings out of the evil. If these good people realize that they have been snookered by the Vatican elites and churchmen, maybe they will give up that hopeless endeavor and embrace promoting real traditionalism, the Traditional Latin Mass, and begin to fight the real crisis, which is a crisis of faith. We can only pray.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

O help! That photo is shocking! Dear sweet Lord - what is going on in Your Church?
ReplyDeleteBarbara
The photo is of him washing the feet of pregnant mothers. I think is is beautiful!
DeleteTo do so in the context of a Holy Thursday Liturgy, since the washing of feet is reserved to men alone, is a sacrilege.
DeleteThe Faith is held by a small remnant and that remnant is the true Church of our Lord. It is that Church which shall never fail.
ReplyDeleteit will be very interesting to see their reaction to his changes. I have a feeling they will, by and large, simple change their sensibilities to fit the new paradigm. I'd be very curious to see how someone like Jimmy Akin, Shea, Koffin(sp?), et al would handle an on air question (in a worried voice) along the lines of " I really loved Benedict's liturgies, they really helped me come to see the beauty of God and the Holy Mass. But what I've seen with Francis worries me. Im afraid we might lose the nobility and beauty we had with Benedict. What should we think about these changes? Should we be worried?" I bet they, and those like them, would try to balance an appreciation and love for the "Benedictine renewal" as being needed then, with the insistence of Frances' liturgies as what we need now. That would be consistent with their flawed liturgical/ecclesiastical mindset which views traditional liturgies/dogmas as "good then", but the modern practices and beliefs are what we "need now".
Delete